AI Tools & Software

beehiiv vs Substack: Fees, Growth Tools and Who Each Platform Suits

Abstract blue chart graphic with the label Beehiiv Vs Substack

beehiiv vs Substack is the first big decision for most new newsletter writers, and it is mostly a decision about money. Substack is free to start and takes a cut of paid revenue. beehiiv charges a monthly fee for its paid plans and focuses on growth and advertising tools. The writing experience on both is good, so the better question is how you plan to earn and grow. A note on timing: beehiiv renamed and repriced its plans in October 2026, so beehiiv prices below are attributed to beehiiv's own pricing guide and may change again. Check both vendors before you commit.

The short answer

  • You want to write, find readers and maybe charge later: Substack is the easiest start, with no upfront cost and a built-in reader network.
  • You plan to run the newsletter like a business with ads, sponsors and paid tiers: beehiiv's flat fees and growth tools usually work out cheaper and give you more control.
  • You already have an audience elsewhere: beehiiv's free plan and custom website make it a strong home base.

beehiiv vs Substack at a glance

beehiivSubstack
Cost to startFree plan, up to 2,500 subscribersFree
Paid newsletter feesMonthly plan; 0% beehiiv take rate on paid subscriptions from Lite up, plus Stripe fees10% of paid revenue plus Stripe fees
Paid plansLite and Pro (formerly Scale and Max), priced by list size; Lite from $49/month billed yearly at 1,000 subscribers, per beehiiv's pricing guideNone needed
Ads and sponsorsAd network on paid plansNo built-in ad network
DiscoveryRecommendations, referral program, paid BoostsReader app and network, recommendations
Best forBusiness-minded publishersWriters who value simplicity and community

beehiiv figures come from beehiiv's 2026 pricing guide, as shown after its October repricing (Lite is $59 billed monthly at 1,000 subscribers). According to beehiiv's October 2026 announcement, existing customers see no change until their first renewal on or after November 1, 2026, and annual customers keep their current price until their term renews. Prices rise with list size, so enter your subscriber count on beehiiv's pricing page.

How the money works

Substack: free until you earn

Substack charges nothing for free newsletters. When you turn on paid subscriptions, it takes 10% of that revenue, and Stripe charges card processing on top. Stripe's fees are 2.9% plus 30 cents per transaction, plus a 0.7% billing fee on recurring subscriptions, according to Substack's help center. On a $10 monthly subscription, that leaves the writer roughly $8.30 to $8.40.

That model is friendly when revenue is small. At $200 a month in paid subscriptions, Substack's cut is $20. It gets expensive as you grow: at $5,000 a month, the 10% cut is $500 every month.

beehiiv: a flat fee instead of a cut

beehiiv's paid plans charge a monthly fee that rises with subscriber count, and beehiiv lists a 0% take rate on paid subscriptions from the Lite plan up. Stripe processing fees still apply. If your paid revenue is meaningful, a flat fee is usually cheaper than a 10% cut. If you never charge readers, the Free plan may be all you need until you pass its subscriber limit.

A quick break-even check

Take your expected monthly paid revenue and multiply by 0.10. That is roughly Substack's cut. Compare it with the beehiiv plan price for your list size on beehiiv's pricing page. Whichever is lower wins on cost; then weigh the features below.

Growth and discovery

Substack's network effect

Substack's biggest strength is its reader ecosystem. Readers browse publications in the app, follow writers and get recommendations from newsletters they already read. For a new writer with no audience, that discovery can be the difference between 50 and 500 subscribers in the first months.

beehiiv's growth tools

beehiiv leans on tools you control: a referral program, recommendations between newsletters, and Boosts, where other publishers pay to be recommended or you pay to gain subscribers. Combined with an ad network on paid plans, it is built for publishers who treat growth as a system.

Writing, design and AI

Both editors are clean and fast. beehiiv offers more control over the design of your website and posts. Substack keeps things simple, which many writers prefer.

AI fits around either platform:

Whatever tool drafts the issue, read it before sending. Readers subscribe for your judgment, not a model's.

Owning your audience

On either platform, your subscriber list is the asset that matters. Export it every month and keep a copy outside the platform. Use your own custom domain where possible, so links in old issues keep working if you move. And keep your welcome email and best posts saved in your own documents. Those habits make the platform choice reversible.

Which one should you choose?

Choose Substack if

  • You are starting from zero and want discovery.
  • You want to write without managing a business stack.
  • Paid revenue will be modest for the first year.

Choose beehiiv if

  • You plan to sell ads or sponsorships.
  • You expect paid revenue large enough that 10% hurts.
  • You want your own website, design control and growth tools.

FAQ

How much does Substack take from paid subscriptions?

Substack's help center says publishing is free and Substack takes 10% of paid subscription revenue. Stripe adds card processing (2.9% plus 30 cents per transaction) and a 0.7% billing fee on recurring subscriptions. Fees can change, so check before you price your newsletter.

Is beehiiv free?

Yes. beehiiv's Free plan (formerly Launch) covers up to 2,500 subscribers, according to beehiiv's October 2026 pricing update. Monetization features such as paid subscriptions and the ad network sit on paid plans. beehiiv repriced its plans in October 2026, so confirm limits on its pricing page.

Which is cheaper, beehiiv or Substack?

For a free newsletter, both can cost nothing. For a paid newsletter, Substack's 10% cut grows with revenue, while beehiiv charges a monthly plan fee. Once your paid revenue is a few hundred dollars a month, a flat fee is usually cheaper.

Can I move from Substack to beehiiv later?

Yes. Both platforms let you export your subscriber list, and beehiiv offers import tools. Moving paying subscribers involves Stripe, so plan the switch carefully and test with a small group.

Which has better discovery?

Substack has a reader network and app where people find new publications. beehiiv relies more on growth tools such as referral programs, recommendations and paid Boosts.

Verdict

In beehiiv vs Substack, Substack is the lower-risk start for writers who want readers first and money later. beehiiv is the better long-term home for anyone running a newsletter as a business, because a flat fee beats a 10% cut once paid revenue grows, and its ad and growth tools are deeper. Run the break-even check above with your own numbers.

Sources and methodology

Desk research. Substack fees come from Substack's help center article "How much does Substack cost?" (https://support.substack.com/hc/en-us/articles/360037607131). beehiiv's old-to-new plan names (Launch to Free, Scale to Lite, Max to Pro), the renewal terms and the 0% take rate come from beehiiv's announcement "beehiiv Launches New Plans and Pricing (October 2026)" (https://www.beehiiv.com/blog/beehiiv-pricing-2026). The 2,500-subscriber Free limit and Lite and Pro prices at 1,000 subscribers come from beehiiv's "2026 Guide to beehiiv Prices" (https://www.beehiiv.com/blog/email-marketing-pricing). Both pages were read in full on 15 October 2026. beehiiv's main pricing page blocked automated access, so we could not confirm custom domain availability there; verify at https://www.beehiiv.com/pricing before deciding.